4 Things to Look For When Choosing the Best Flooring for Rental Property (And Which Types Are the Most Popular)

best flooring for rental property

Whether you’ve just invested in a brand-new Airbnb or have been renting your place for a while now, there comes a time when you’ll need to redo your floors. With so many types and options to choose from, selecting the best flooring for your rental property can be quite tricky. 

What is the Best Flooring for a Rental Property?

While much of the goal of short-term renting is making money, you’ll have to consider different factors in trying to achieve that goal. Attracting guests, hosting them on your property, and providing a great product are just some of them. You’ll also want to retain your guests, have them come back again, and have them recommend you to others.

If you’re looking to resell your property in the future, that would be another consideration. Aside from a room’s walls, flooring can often be the focal point in a room’s interior. You’ll want to not only invest in attractive and high-quality materials for your floors, but you’ll also want to keep them in good shape so you can increase the resale value of your property in the future.

So what are the things you need to consider when choosing the best flooring material for your Airbnb?

1. Durability

Most short-term and vacation rental properties see a lot of foot traffic. Guests stay at frequent intervals, lugging heavy suitcases in and out. Children and animals – if your property is pet-friendly – could cause all kinds of mess on the floor.

Properties near the beach, lake, or mountains will be exposed to lots of water, sand, mud, and grit.

Depending on where your listing is and what type of guests you accommodate, your flooring will have specific needs. Whichever way, you’ll want it to be durable so it can stand many, many years of wear and tear.

2. Ease of maintenance

Whether you’re renting your property for the short, medium, or long term, ease of maintenance is a key factor. Choosing a type of flooring that’s easy to clean will make it easy not just for yourself and your cleaners, but also for your guests if they need to take care of spills and smudges on your floor.

3. Aesthetics

Of course, everybody wants great visual appeal. In most cases, guests book rental properties based on what they see on a listing’s photos. They want to see clean, modern homes, especially if the property is located in the city. And that includes updated flooring! If you own the property you’re renting (and not doing rental arbitrage), the aesthetics will be an especially crucial factor if you end up reselling your place in the future.

4. Affordability

Short-term renting is a business, and good business involves cost-cutting for better efficiency. You won’t want to spend on expensive marble or natural stone floors. You’ll want value for money so can cut down on unnecessary costs while maintaining all the other factors mentioned above.

But note that affordability doesn’t end with the purchase of any flooring material you end up with. You’d also have to factor in the installation, maintenance, and possible replacement costs down the road.

5 Best Flooring Types to Choose From

So what type of flooring will rent your property faster? Which ones will provide great value for your money? And which materials will weather a lot of wear and tear? Here are the 5 best flooring materials you can choose from.

1. Carpet

Carpets bring warmth, comfort, and color to any room. Because of their ability to provide extra insulation for heat and sound, they’re a popular choice for apartments and condominiums. They’re highly recommended for bedrooms and playrooms. Landlords especially love them for their affordability and ease of installation.

The downside is that carpets are susceptible to water damage. If moisture seeps into them and spreads underneath, molds can grow and potentially pose health hazards. So they can’t be recommended for use in kitchens, bathrooms, basements, and dining area.

PROS

  • Provides great insulation, increasing energy efficiency – ideal for cold climates
  • Soft and comfortable
  • Reduces noise. Great for bedrooms and hallways
  • Very fast and easy to install
  • The cheapest flooring option there is
  • Extremely versatile. They come in unlimited types, from thick and cozy to smooth and sturdy. There are also unlimited colors, and patterns to match any theme (best to go plain and neutral though)
  • Prevents or softens slips and falls

CONS

  • Absorbs dust, moisture, stains, odors, and pet dander – – not suited for pet-friendly listings
  • Conducive environment for dust mites, pests, and other allergens 
  • Extremely high maintenance – needs regular vacuuming and periodic shampooing
  • Stains, tears, and burns aren’t easily removed or fixed; if one area is damaged, the entire carpet may need to be replaced
  • Not durable. It gets worn down in high-traffic areas over time, so you may need to replace it after just a few years

2. Hardwood

Probably nothing looks richer, homier, and more beautiful than good old wooden floors – the genuine kind, that is! Natural and totally unique in texture, this organic material comes in a plethora of grains and tones that will go with any property’s color scheme. Best suited for rooms with less foot traffic like bedrooms, dining, and living room, hardwood has an elegant, timeless appeal that will never go out of style.

PROS

  • Very durable, it lasts 30+ years before needing refinishing
  • Easy to clean and maintain
  • Lots of styles and finishes to choose from
  • Likely to increase the value of your rental property, in case you decide to sell in the future

CONS

  • Prone to dents, scratches, and stains (but can be resanded and refinished. To protect the wood, you can use an area rug to cover high-traffic areas.)
  • Susceptible to moisture and humidity. Not ideal for beach rentals and tropical climates
  • Contracts and expands during different seasons
  • Hard to repair a small damaged section
  • Very costly

3. laminates

Also known as the “poor man’s hardwood”, laminates are made with four different layers of synthetic materials compacted together. A high-resolution photo of natural wood or stone is printed onto the fiberboard and then laminated with a stain-resistant coating. The planks are usually installed over a subfloor by gluing or clicking together. 

Laminates are popular because of their affordability. They can match the elegant look of wood and stone but only cost a fraction of the price. Plus, they don’t scratch and discolor easily like genuine lumber. 

Laminates are ideal for properties that allow pets. They’re recommended for use in high-traffic areas of the home like the kitchen and living room. But since they’re less durable than genuine wood, they’ll need replacement after several years. So the cost you’d save in installing laminates could otherwise go to replacement costs in the future.

PROS

  • One of the cheapest flooring options there is
  • Very easy to clean – just mop and go
  • Can last 10-15 years for lower-end types; double that length for higher quality ones with proper installation
  • Easy to install
  • Replacing damaged section is quick and simple
  • Doesn’t trap dust and allergens
  • Functional and attractive, with almost unlimited options in designs and colors
best flooring for rental property

CONS

  • Not resistant to moisture — which can cause bubbles and swells
  • Feels hard underfoot and can be noisy
  • The artificial look of faux wood may not appeal to the discriminating eye
  • Prone to scratches, scuffs
  • Damages can’t be fixed 

4. Luxury vinyl tiles or planks (LVTs/LVPs)

LVTs and LVPs are the highest quality vinyl flooring. They’re preferred over standard vinyl composite tiles (VCT) because of their texture and durability. LVTs can match not only the high-end look of hardwood, ceramic and polished stone but also their surface grain. Plus, many are water-proof which means they can be installed anywhere, including bathrooms, kitchens, laundry rooms, and basements.  

PROS

  • Most are dirt and water-resistant, unaffected by moisture, steam, or humidity. So  you won’t have problems with stains, molds, and mildew
  • Softer on the feet than  tiles and wood
  • Hardy against scratches, scuffs, and punctures
  • Low maintenance – no need for waxing, oiling, polishing, sealing, or staining 
  • Lightweight and installation is DIY-friendly
  • Looks similar to many high-end flooring types but a lot cheaper

CONS

  • Less durable than wood, tiles, and stone
  • Cannot be repaired, re-sanded, or refinished
  • Difficult to remove since the glue used is highly adhesive
  • The perfect, even texture of the “grain” doesn’t match the characteristic imperfection and raw texture of real wood or stone
  • Difficult to recycle and not eco-friendly

5. tiles

Ceramic and porcelain tiles are a durable, versatile, and popular flooring option among rental owners. They come in a vast array of styles, price points, sizes, and designs that can imitate stone, wood, and other natural materials. Plus, they’re very easy to clean and maintain. The downside is that installation can be costly. The best places to install tiles in a rental property would be the bathroom, kitchen, entryway, mudroom, and basement.

PROS

  • Doesn’t stain, scratch or retain odors
  • Low maintenance
  • Highly durable, can last a lifetime
  • Good for allergy-sensitive guests

CONS 

  • Hard and costly to install
  • Pricey
  • Cold to the feel. Not recommended for cooler climates
  • Can crack under certain circumstances (heavy object being dropped, structural/foundation issues, or incorrect installation)
  • Slippery when wet
  • The grout needs periodic deep cleaning or replacing over time 
  • The weight may not be suited for high-level units.

So what is the best flooring for a rental property?

When deciding among the best flooring options, the usual approach is to use two or more different materials. But don’t limit your considerations to just durability and cost. There are a lot of other factors that you need to think about: the climate in your property’s location, the function of each room, the type of guests you’re trying to attract, their safety, and the time and effort you’ll spend on installation, maintenance, and repairs. The effort you’ll need to put in if you decide to change or upgrade the materials in the future can also be a factor. 

Weigh those different elements and find out if you can find a sweet spot somewhere in between. Then, decide how the pros of each of the flooring materials listed above can work for the different areas of your property.

Learn How to Manage Airbnb Properties Better

Ready to learn how we built and operate a $2M/year short-term rental business, operate properties throughout the USA remotely, and acquired 70+ properties without owning any in just 2 years? Attend our free online master class to learn how you can do the same. Click here.